Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts

Thursday, December 02, 2010

Lacson cannot dictate terms of surrender: De Lima

MANILA, Philippines – Fugitive Sen. Panfilo “Ping” Lacson cannot dictate the conditions of his surrender, Department of Justice (DOJ) Secretary Leila de Lima said Thursday.

De Lima said Lacson should follow the advice of his lawyer, Alexander Poblador, and follow the legal process “instead of laying down conditions that are not legally feasible at this point.”
Lacson, who has been charged for the murders of publicist Salvador “Bubby” Dacer and his driver, Emmanuel Corbito, earlier said that he will continue to remain in hiding until justice is served or, in his own words, “when I’m already dead.”
The Interpol has also placed Lacson, a former director-general of the Philippine National Police, on its "red notice" list of international fugitives.
“Senator Lacson has a standing warrant of arrest and is a fugitive from justice. He knows that his present status does not accord him the privilege of laying down terms with a tenor of finality,” de Lima said.
The senator wants her to ask the courts to reinvestigate his case.
The DOJ chief, however, stressed that her office cannot act on Lacson’s motion for reinvestigation as doing so would violate the law. “The DOJ cannot, at this point, review what is for the courts to decide.”
Lacson, through his lawyer, had filed a second motion for reconsideration before the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Manila in his bid to have his case reinvestigated. He also filed a petition for certiorari with the Court of Appeals with regard to the Manila RTC’s denial of his first motion for reconsideration.
“The issue of reinvestigation is now a single incident pending before 2 courts, the RTC and the Court of Appeals. The DOJ is without jurisdiction to preempt the decision of 2 courts of law on this matter,” she explained.
Surrender first

She said that Lacson's statements could be overtures for negotiating terms of his surrender that should not include involving the lifting of his warrant of arrest and the granting of his motion for reinvestigation.

“The issues Lacson has raised as conditions for his surrender, such as the granting of his motion for reinvestigation, should be discussed after his coming back into the fold of the law,” de Lima said. “If the new evidence as presented by Lacson's lawyers is indeed meritorious, at least one of the 2 courts of law which have jurisdiction over the incident will rule in Lacson's favor, and the DOJ will respect that ruling.”
De Lima added that the most that the DOJ can do is to withdraw its opposition to Lacson's motion for reinvestigation. “Lacson's surrender should precede any favorable response that may come from the government. Surrender, under criminal law, is a mitigating circumstance that can be properly appreciated not only by the courts but also by the DOJ.”
She said the government has to enforce the law and implement the arrest warrant against the senator.
“Any government concession will have to depend on Lacson's show of good faith and respect for our laws which apply to everyone, senator and ordinary citizen alike,” she said.
The DOJ chief also allayed Lacson’s concerns regarding his personal safety after he gives himself up.
“Given his stature, Senator Lacson has no reason to fear that he will be treated differently and persecuted by the government. But his refusal to return to the fold of the law and observe the legal processes will only galvanize the government's resolve to take him into custody, not to persecute him, but to enable him both to properly face his accusers, and to defend his innocence in the only venue where it can be sufficiently proven, in a court of law,” de Lima said.
Palace can’t interfere
The Palace echoed de Lima’s stand on the issue.
Deputy Presidential spokesperson Abigail Valte said the case, including Lacson’s appeal for reinvestigation, is now in the courts’ hands.
"We welcome the fact that Senator Lacson has broken his silence on the issue," Valte said Thursday. "From what I understand there are already two courts that are hearing this matter. So hindi naman po yung executive ang magde-decide nito. Korte na ang may hawak ng kaso."
She said the senator will be given due process after he surrenders. "The fact remains that we will afford him due process if he decides to submit himself to the justice system."
The MalacaƱang deputy spokesperson declined to comment on Lacson’s apparent distrust of the Aquino administration. "Hindi ko naman po gusto [lagyan] ng kulay yun mga naging statement po ni Senator Lacson dahil yun po yung kanyang saloobin.”
She also explained that the P2-million peso bounty on Lacson’s head is just a proposal.
Fairness
Aside from a criminal case, Lacson is also facing an ethics complaint in the Senate.
The Volunteers Against Crime and Corruption filed the complaint amid Lacson’s perceived failure to perform his government duties since he went into hiding.
His colleague, Senate Minority Leader Alan Peter Cayetano, said the ethics committee has yet to act on the complaint.
“The Senate will still have to approve the rules for the ethics committee. I will assure all sides of fairness and due process,” he said.
“I can’t comment on the merits because I have to hear both sides first and be fair in chairing the committee. Having said that, the [Aquino administration] should assure Sen. Ping of justice, due process and that he will be safe if detained,” Cayetano said.
He also urged Lacson to surrender. “Sen. Ping should surface and realize the DOJ and the courts have to treat him like any other fugitive from justice.”

Monday, January 18, 2010

Marlene Aguilar faces raps for hiding son Jason Ivler

MANILA, Philippines - Marlene Aguilar-Pollard is to be charged with obstruction of justice after prosecutors indicted her for allegedly hiding her son, murder suspect Jason Ivler, inside her home.

Ivler, 26, was arrested inside his parents' home at Blue Ridge village in Quezon City on Monday morning by National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) special action units.

He was wanted for the murder of Renato Victor Ebarle Jr., son of Palace official Renato Ebarle Sr.

In previous statements, Aguilar repeatedly denied that she knew her son's whereabouts. She claimed that Ivler had escaped to the United States.

Police had filed a complaint against Aguilar before the Quezon City Prosecutor's Office for violating Presidential Decree No. 1829, which penalizes people who harbor wanted criminals, conceal evidence, or give false information to prevent law enforcement agents from apprehending suspects.

Alessandro Jurado, a fiscal at the city prosecutor's office, said there was sufficient evidence to file a charge against Aguilar.

Aguilar's case will be brought before the Regional Trial Court on Tuesday. The case can then be raffled by Thursday.

However, Aguilar said she will be posting bail, set at P12,000. "I will post bail. I won't comment because my son is in critical state," said Aguilar, who submitted to a formal inquest at the fiscal's office.

Aguilar, the sister of folk singer Freddie Aguilar, is a self-published book author.

She is married to economist Stephen Pollard, a British national and consultant at the Asian Development Bank.

Jason Ivler is Aguilar's son from a previous marriage to an American.

Repeated denials

Jason Ivler, the primary suspect in the murder of a Palace official's son, is wounded and captured in a police raid inside his mother's home.

The NBI's intelligence reports revealed that Ivler had been hiding at his mother's house in Blue Ridge for more than 2 months.

Police had searched Aguilar's home twice before, but failed to locate the suspect.

The NBI reportedly had strong suspicions that Aguilar was hiding Ivler after they found the suspect's car parked at the house of his uncle in Marikina.

At around 6 a.m. on Monday, the NBI raided Aguilar's home and found Ivler hiding inside a concealed room under the stairs. Ivler shot at police and wounded 2 agents before he was subdued.

Aguilar was arrested, along with 2 male household help, after her son's capture.

Atty. Angelito Magno, head of NBI's Special Action Unit, said Aguilar deliberately misled police when she said her son was out of the country.

"She kept on saying that she received an e-mail that he is in Hawaii already," Magno told reporters in a briefing.

"Second, [Marlene] said things like, 'I am very cooperative. I let you into my home because I have nothing to hide.' Even as her son was shooting at us and we were shooting back, she said, 'I didn't know [Jason] was inside the house'," Magno added.

Police had a standing order for Ivler's arrest after he shot dead 27-year-old Ebarle Jr. in November 2009 following a traffic altercation along Santolan Road in Quezon City.

Ivler, a former U.S. Special Forces agent in Iraq, was involved in a road rage case 4 years ago.

He was charged with reckless imprudence resulting in homicide for killing Undersecretary Nestor Ponce Jr. in 2004 after Ponce accidentally hit his car.

No search warrant

In November 2009, Marlene Aguilar asked her son to surrender to authorities. Police believe Aguilar has been hiding Jason Ivler inside her home since last year and lied to authorities about it.

Aguilar, clad in a nightgown, denied that her son was at home at first and tearfully protested against the NBI's presence at their home.

She also questioned why police had no search warrant when they raided the house. (Watch exclusive ABS-CBN footage of Ivler's arrest here.)

"Wala naman kayong search warrant. Andiyan na siya--andiyan na kayo sa kuwarto ko, may mga hawak kayong baril. Pasensiya ka na ha, ngayon lang ako nagf-freak out," Aguilar was quoted as saying in a videotape of the raid.

(You don't have a search warrant. You're there in my room carrying guns. I'm sorry, I'm freaking out just now.)

Aguilar later led police into Ivler's bedroom to show that it was empty. However, NBI agents noticed the airconditioning unit was on and that the adjacent bathroom had a wet floor and damp towel--indicating the recent presence of an occupant.

They found the suspect hiding inside a tiny storage room that was walled-up on all sides. Ivler, who was carrying a baby armalite and caliber .45 pistol, opened fire on police and started a 10-minute shootout.

Ivler was wounded in the clash, along with 2 police agents, and was brought to the Quezon Memorial Medical Center (QMMC) for treatment.

According to the QMMC's latest medical bulletin, Ivler is "stable but guarded."

NBI agents are standing guard over the patient, who is reportedly handcuffed to his hospital bed. Ivler is currently recuperating from a 3-hour surgery.

'State of shock'

Police handcuff Marlene Aguilar following her son's arrest. She is to be charged for obstruction of justice.

Marlene Aguilar-Pollard appeared distraught when she was escorted to NBI headquarters in handcuffs.

"At the moment, I am in a state of shock. I heard that my son is fighting for life and death. And so I really don't have anything further to say," she said.

Though glib with media, she was videotaped crying several times as she spoke with her lawyer, Atty. Alexis Medina.

Medina declined to comment while investigations are ongoing.

On November 21 last year, Aguilar was also videotaped in a tearful state when she addressed a crowd at the Cultural Center of the Philippines. In her speech, she asked her son to surrender to authorities.

She also apologized to Ebarle Jr.'s family for her son's actions.

"Jason, I say if you are guilty, I beg you with all my heart to surrender yourself and face this," Aguilar had said.

NBI agents, however, insist Aguilar knowingly hid her son from police all these months and fed them false information about his whereabouts.

Though she could have acted based on her natural instinct as a mother to protect her child, Magno said she hampered another family's quest for justice.

Police are currently investigating whether Ivler's stepfather Stephen Pollard, who lives in the same house as Aguilar, is criminally liable.

Pollard is exempt from criminal prosecution due to diplomatic immunity.